Mystery Tackle Box42 reviews
This score is based on 42 genuine reviews submitted via US-Reviews since 2023.
Featured Reviews
Reviews (42)
No reviews yet!
Find companies you have experience with and write reviews about them! Your reviews contribute to a more transparent market and improve the reliability of companies.Unexpected renewal after gifting
Right in the middle of the evening, after the recipient tore open the box, I noticed how solid it felt in hand — nice weight, clean seams, the kind of thing you don't expect at this price. We used it right away and it was comfortable, simple to operate, and actually lasted longer than I thought on a single charge, which was a pleasant surprise. My problem isn't the product; it's how the purchase and account were handled. I bought a one-month gift plan, checked my account on my phone and saw nothing about a recurring subscription, so I assumed it was a single purchase. A month later they charged me again. I requested immediate cancellation and offered to return the unopened item, but support was unhelpful and refused both requests. So yeah, good product feel and unexpected battery life, but the billing and service left me stuck and disputing the charge.
Mystery box, mixed feelings
The first box hit me like a little surprise. It smelled like new plastic and felt neatly packed, and I actually grinned opening it — I’d just moved and didn’t want to rebuild my tackle collection from scratch, so this seemed perfect. The lures themselves felt solid in the hand. Some were weighted just right, casting easy, and one crankbait had a nice wobble on the first cast that got a few follows. I liked the QR videos too; watching a short demo helped more than the tiny leaflet would. Still, after a few months the novelty faded. Boxes started to feel inconsistent. Some months I got neat little tools or a really useful jig. Other months I pulled out stuff I already had or things that sat in my box untouched. Value claims didn’t always match what I could find in stores, which was annoying. Shipping usually wasn’t a problem, though a couple went late and I didn’t hear anything for a while. Customer support was polite when they replied, but the replies came slow. So yeah, it’s handy if you want variety and don’t want to hunt for every lure yourself. Not perfect. Works most of the time. I’ll keep it for the surprises, just with lower expectations now.
Bait meh, delivery saved me
Needed it for a bad back move; service was patient and delivery fast, felt kind of lucky
Hooked faster, no joke
Started last weekend — feels great, hooked more fish
Quietly decent start
First day use — surprised, finally worth it
Quiet win
I doubted these. First morning lake cast — hooked, kept coming.
Caught me smiling
Halfway through unboxing, saw it on a friend's post; delivery quick, service helpful.
Small switch-up
Love it overall — breaks up my same-old toast routine, fresh flavor during morning coffee; little crumbly sometimes but still fun.
Mid-cast grin
Started using these lures last weekend — felt great in hand, easy to cast, surprised there were no tutorial links, still happy
Repeat pick
Saw them at a market, tipped a friend; ordered a few, delivery was prompt, customer service replied fast—glad it worked.
Same haul, different day
Thought they'd vary, but both boxes had identical cheap gear; delivery was slow, customer service surprised me with a quick refund, which really helped.
Two boxes, different contents
Got two boxes about a week apart; first felt like a cheap sample, second actually had decent stuff. Needed this for a move—was hoping for consistency, but meh.
That 'got it' moment
When the latest box showed up I actually laughed — everything fit our taste. That's the moment I knew. I'd tried other subs and this one finally delivers. Gonna gift it to Dad.
Decent box, mixed feelings
Opening it I was halfway regretting the buy — had been burned by other boxes before — but it’s decent. Only two saltwater items though, rest freshwater, kind of meh.
Gifted subscription, eh
Halfway through month three, holding a tiny soap and a flimsy lip balm — supposed to be $25 — felt cheap. Surprisingly, one small brush actually works compared to before
Decent pick for beginners
I’d recommend it — the subscription boxes are handy for newbies and make easy gifts; I’ve tried other services and this one felt more practical, not flashy.
Twice the box, mixed feelings
a bit careless, but after using it I was glad it worked, though they should fix this.
Gift turned subscription hassle
I bought a three-month membership for a friend and I was worried it would auto-renew, so I canceled it after the gift period. That was over a month ago, but I just got a shipping notice for another box. Service works in the sense packages arrive, but billing and support dropped the ball. I want the charges reversed and the shipments stopped.
Half the haul
Started skeptical because mystery boxes can be hit or miss. I grabbed two inshore saltwater pro boxes for weekend trips. At home I found one was actually a bass mystery box. That annoyed me, not what I paid for, but the other box was spot on and the gear helps with my daily bait prep. Mixed feelings.
Forum tip worked
tracking updates were thin, otherwise fine. Would use again.
About Mystery Tackle Box
Fishing is one of the most fun activities to engage in. There are various techniques in catching fish such as trapping, netting, spearing, and hand gathering. It is important to have the required or complete fishing gear products before embarking on the activity. If you need fish gear products, there are many places to get them. One of the online places you can visit for fish gear products is Mystery Tackle Box. The company delivers fishing supplies in a mystery box to subscribers. But how dedicated are their personnel attendants? Are their products and services reasonably priced? You should read honest customer reviews of Mystery Tackle Box here to get suggestive answers to your questions.
About Mystery Tackle Box
Mystery Tackle Box is a monthly subscription service for fishing gear products. The privately-held company was founded by Ross Gordon in 2012 and is headquartered in Chicago, Illinois, United States. They proclaim to feature over a hundred different brands in their boxes and have introduced tens of thousands of anglers to new products. They boast of shipping out over 2 million baits a year and continue to grow as their customers love getting their boxes every month. The company affirms that their boxes are comprised of a mixture of sample packages of terminal tackle and soft plastics and full retail package hard baits.
Products and Services of Mystery Tackle Box
The fish species available on Mystery Tackle Box website are largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, spotted bass, redfish, speckled trout, snook, flounder, crappie, perch, bluegill and trout, walleye, and sauger. Their subscription plans are Regular, Pro and Elite. The plan duration options are monthly, 3-month, 6-month and 12-month. Each month, a subscriber is offered a variety of fishing products from both small and large manufacturers. Each bait put inside the box is reviewed by their product specialists who are maintained to be experienced, tournament fishermen. Subscribers can change their box type from their account's dashboard. Their preferred box type must be specified by the last day of the month for the change to take effect for the next shipment. The customer can cancel or stop their Mystery Tackle Box for a selected number of months or finally. Once a subscription is canceled, the customer can still receive all boxes they have already paid for. All payments are processed on the 1st day of each month and shipping is carried out within 10 working days of order. Mystery Tackle Box ships to the continental US and Canada. They offer both standard and expedited shipping. The subscription boxes are non-refundable and ineligible for returns. They offer a 30-day limited return policy for the following products - Reels, Rods, Apparel, and fishing accessories.
Compliments, Complaints, and Tips for Mystery Tackle Box
What fishing products have you gotten so far from Mystery Tackle Box? Did you select the type of species of fish you want? What do you benefit from your subscription? Between the regular subscription and gift subscription, which one are you subscribed to? Are you able to change your box type? Was it easy for you to redeem your gift certificate? What day of the month do they usually charge you? Share your fishing experience using Mystery Tackle Box products. Your feedback will improve the company's services to serve customers better.
Details
Contact Information
Categories Mystery Tackle Box
Page Statistics
Last update: March 2026
Advertising notice: Some links are affiliate links. For purchases made through them, we may receive a commission – at no additional cost to you.
Review with most votes
Mystery Tackle Box Review
I have been a subscriber of Mystery Tackle Box for several months now, and I have been extremely impressed with the quality and variety of the fishing lures and accessories that... Read onBy: Emile Tremblay