GemsNY Reviews

: 19
100% Would buy here again

Most relevant positive review

  2024-03-24
Solitaire engagement ring
My wife and I picked out this really pretty solitaire engagement ring, but she wasn't feelin...Read on
Velma

Review with most votes

  2023-01-12
Mediocre experience with GemsN
As a customer of GemsNY, I have had mixed experiences with the company. On one hand, their select...Read on
Lucio Fay

Reviews (19)

  (17)

 (2)

  (0)

  (0)

  (0)

  • No reviews yet!

    Find companies you have experience with and write reviews about them! Your reviews contribute to a more transparent market and improve the reliability of companies.

  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Mediocre experience with GemsNY

    As a customer of GemsNY, I have had mixed experiences with the company. On one hand, their selection of jewelry is impressive and they have a wide variety of options to choose from. The prices are also quite reasonable, especially considering the quality of the products.

    However, my main issue with GemsNY has been their customer service. I have reached out to them multiple times with questions and concerns, but the responses I have received have been slow and not particularly helpful. Additionally, I have had trouble with a few of my orders and had to follow up multiple times to get them resolved.

    Overall, I would recommend GemsNY for their selection and prices, but be prepared to do your own research and possibly follow up on any issues you may have. The company does not have physical stores and the customer service could be better.


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Diamond earrings purchase

    I just bought these amazing diamond earrings from this company and let me tell you, I was seriously impressed with their customer service and the quality of the product. I originally picked out a pair with some specific details in mind, but then Jonathan hit me up and said he found some even better diamonds for the same price. And let me tell you, these new diamonds were bigger, better cut, and just overall higher quality than what I was expecting. When the earrings finally arrived, they were just absolutely gorgeous. I ended up giving them to my wife for our anniversary and she was completely blown away by how beautiful and sparkly they were. Honestly, I would highly recommend this company to anyone in the market for some top-notch jewelry and amazing customer service.


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Ruby and gold ring for wife's birthday

    My time on the jewelry company's website was amazing. It was really easy to use, so I had no trouble looking through all the different gems and settings they offer. The pictures and info about each piece were super clear, which made it simple for me to find a beautiful ruby that fit my budget. Vishal, the customer service rep, was so helpful and really knew his stuff. He gave me great advice on choosing the perfect ruby and made sure I found the right one for my wife's birthday. The paperwork that came with my order was detailed and can even be used for insurance, which made me feel even better about my purchase. I've already told my friends and family about this company and I'll definitely be buying from them again in the future.


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Sapphire ring purchase

    I recently got this really pretty sapphire ring and let me tell you, my experience with the company was amazing. I was on the hunt for the perfect sapphire ring for a while and then I found GemsNY's website. They had so much detailed info about the gemstone like the color, clarity, weight, and where it came from. It was way more info than other jewelry sites I checked out. Plus, I could choose different settings for the stone which was great because I could make the ring exactly how I wanted. The price was totally fair too, especially for the quality of the sapphire and how well-made the ring is. I'm super happy with my purchase and definitely recommend GemsNY to anyone looking for top-notch gemstone jewelry.


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Solitaire engagement ring

    My wife and I picked out this really pretty solitaire engagement ring, but she wasn't feeling too comfortable with how the stone stuck out. She was worried about it getting in the way during her active daily routine. So, we decided to reach out to a jeweler for some advice. They gave us some options for a new setting that would work better for her lifestyle, and now she's absolutely thrilled with how the ring looks.


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Ruby and diamond ring purchase

    I just got this amazing ruby and diamond ring from an online jewelry store with a ton of options to choose from. The price was good, and the ring itself is really well-made and beautiful. I liked how the website let me see what the finished product would look like with the stones in place. Even though they had to make the ring from scratch, it came earlier than I expected. I'm so happy with my purchase and I'm already thinking about getting some matching ruby earrings soon.


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Sapphire purchase

    I just bought a sapphire from this company and I'm super happy with it! The quality and customer service were top-notch. I wanted a non-heated, certified sapphire that wouldn't break the bank, and the expert I dealt with really took great care of me. They were so patient in explaining all the different colors, how vibrant they were, and the value of the stones I was interested in. I found a gorgeous sapphire that matched my budget and preferences perfectly. I'm thrilled with my purchase and would definitely suggest this company to anyone looking for gemstones.


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Sapphire ring purchase

    The sapphire ring I got from this company is so beautiful, it's just amazing. The color of the sapphire is absolutely stunning, it sparkles in any light. The setting is really well-made, solid, and super attractive. The size of the ring was perfect and it fits perfectly on my finger. I searched online for days to find the best quality, value, and reputation, and I can honestly say that no other jeweler can compare to this company. I am so impressed with my purchase and I will definitely be coming back for more jewelry in the future.


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Ruby earrings for my mom's birthday

    I wanted to find something super special for my mom's milestone birthday, so I went with a pair of ruby earrings. I was clueless on where to even begin, but thankfully I stumbled upon this fantastic shop that guided me through creating the ideal set! The dude assisting me, we'll call him Jonny, was incredibly friendly and made sure I knew what was going on every step of the way. The earrings came out even more amazing than I had pictured! I'm so excited to see the look on my mom's face when she unwraps them!


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Custom Aquamarine ring purchase

    Designing that custom Aquamarine and Rose Gold ring was such a great experience! We loved finding the perfect gemstone, and the team really helped us create a stunning piece for my mom. The options in their inventory were amazing, and Vishal kept us updated every step of the way. The pricing was fair, and we got our ring back pretty quickly. The final product was truly a showstopper, especially that beautiful gemstone. We're so happy with our purchase, and GemsNY is now our favorite jeweler by far.


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Customized jewelry purchase

    My experience at Gems NY was amazing. The people there, especially Ernie, really knew their stuff and listened to what I wanted. They made sure I was happy with what I bought, going the extra mile. Their repairs were fast and well done too. One thing I'd mention is maybe thinking about covering the shipping costs for pricier orders, because it can really bump up the total.


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Awesome ring!

    GemsNY is amazing! I recently got a really awesome ring from them and it came out so great! The guy, Ernie, who helped me was super nice and genuine. The only suggestion I have is for them to improve the quality of the pictures and videos of their gems because sometimes you can't see all the details in just the photos. But overall, I definitely plan on purchasing more rings from them!


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Emerald ring purchase

    My experience with the company was amazing! Joseph and Vishal were so knowledgeable and helpful in helping me pick out the perfect emerald stone. Their advice really helped me make the best choice and I am so happy with how it turned out. The Colombian emerald in the ring is stunning and I couldn't be happier with my purchase. Big thanks to the team at the company for their fantastic service and expertise.


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Halo ring purchase

    I just bought my wife a beautiful halo ring as a Christmas present, and I have to tell you, it was even better than I had hoped. The ring was fantastic quality and my wife absolutely loved it. The team was super helpful and quick to respond to all my questions. This was the third time I've bought from these guys, and once again they knocked it out of the park with their service, quality, and prices. I'd definitely recommend them to anyone looking for jewelry.


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Emerald bracelet purchase

    I just got my wife an emerald bracelet from this company for her birthday, and I gotta say, I am super impressed! The bracelet is top-notch quality, even better than I expected, and my wife totally adores it. The customer service team was amazing - they were so helpful and responsive from start to finish. They not only answered all my questions but also gave me great advice on picking out the perfect bracelet.


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Sparkly blue ring

    I picked up this awesome blue ring at this really cool store, and it's got all these shiny rocks on it. I had a blast checking out all the sparkly options with my special someone. The person working there was super friendly and didn't pressure us to make a purchase. We felt all fancy looking at all the sparkly stuff and choosing the perfect one. I'm already excited to go back and get more shiny things!


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Bracelet purchase

    Hey everyone, if you wanna buy somethin' from that place, you gotta chat with Christina. She totally helped me choose a bracelet for my wife and sorted out a little order mix-up. And then she swapped out the bracelet for a slightly different one. Christina is awesome!


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Emerald Ring

    I got this really awesome emerald ring with gold accents on it, and let me tell you, it's my new favorite thing. I was a little nervous about dropping some serious cash on a shiny piece of jewelry online, so I gave Jonathan a call. And I gotta say, he was amazing. Jonathan helped me choose the exact emerald and setting I wanted, and he was quick to answer all my questions. When the ring finally showed up, it totally exceeded my expectations. I'm absolutely in love with it!


  • Ordering

    Service

    Pricing

    Delivery

    Would buy here again
    Overall

    Ruby ring and earrings

    I just bought a ruby ring and earrings from this company, and I gotta say, it was a great experience. The staff showed us a bunch of rubies in different sizes and helped us pick out the exact ones we wanted for our jewelry. They even gave us some design ideas to make each stone look its best. The staff really knew their stuff and made the whole thing super easy and fun. I'm so happy with how everything turned out, and I'll definitely be back for more in the future.


Others also viewed