Only Maker34 reviews
This score is based on 34 genuine reviews submitted via US-Reviews since 2023.
Featured Reviews
Reviews (34)
No reviews yet!
Find companies you have experience with and write reviews about them! Your reviews contribute to a more transparent market and improve the reliability of companies.One pair surprised me
Opened the box and honestly I was relieved — the first pair looked and felt better than I expected. I almost bailed on ordering because of the scary reviews and the weird shipping notes, so yeah I had doubts. That one pair slowly made me less worried, it fits and feels solid. But the other two never showed up and the messages about switching carriers were just confusing. No phone number either, which is annoying. If they clean up tracking and add real support, I’d try them again — for now mixed feelings.
One arrived, the rest MIA
Funny start — one box showed up exactly when I expected, and that pair was fine. After that it went downhill. I ordered three pairs; the seller kept telling me the other two were out for delivery, switched couriers, then supposedly shipped earlier — timelines never matched and nothing turned up. No phone support, just vague messages that danced around the issue. I’m glad one pair worked out, but the back-and-forth and lack of clear tracking left me annoyed. If you need everything together, insist on solid tracking or think twice.
Great feel, shaky returns
First thing I noticed was how soft the leather felt — really nicer than I expected, and they looked great on. The box came beat up and they sent the wrong size, so I messaged them. At first replies were fast and helpful, which I appreciated, but after I sent the shoes back things went quiet. The return address was a house in Jamaica, NY and the slip just said "Kent" with no last name — odd. I sent them anyway and then radio silence after four emails. If they fit you, these are solid shoes; just be ready that returns and follow-up aren't reliable compared to other places I've used.
Nice shoes, frustrating process
I actually liked how the pair looked and felt when I tried them on at home — soft insole, decent support for my quick commutes and dog walks — but that’s where the good part ends. Sizes are wildly inconsistent; I ordered my usual and they were too tight, then an exchange felt like a money sink because returns aren’t free. Email support is glacial, no phone option, and the back-and-forth took ages, which is annoying when you just want wearable shoes. So, not a total disaster — they work fine once you get the right fit — but the hassle and extra costs make me think twice about buying again.
Pretty solid overall
worth a try — especially if you wear a 43+. I ordered from Onlymaker a few weeks ago and at first I thought I’d messed up the size. I corrected it by email and, surprisingly, they switched the order (even to a different model) without any fuss — got a refund so I could place the new order. Shoes arrived feeling solid and comfortable right away, though the box had a small crease and shipping was a day slower than expected. Customer support was actually friendly and quick, which caught me off guard. The site could be clearer about sizes, but overall I’d recommend them.
That first walk
they actually fit, the heel felt stable, and they didn't scream "pain" like some heels do. I've been wearing them for short commutes, quick errands and a couple nights out; still breaking in but okay. Packaging was neat, tracking solid, international shipping faster than I feared. Price seemed fair and customer service was helpful, so overall pretty happy.
Cab-proof comfort
I remember stepping out of the cab and realizing my feet weren't screaming. I'd bought these because my lower back had been killing me after long shifts and my last pair of heels were a disaster. First night out I danced for hours. At around 2 AM I laughed because the pain I expected never came. That's when I knew they worked. They've got a solid inner sole that actually supports you. Not perfect — one pair needed a short break-in and a small scuff showed up after a few uses — but still way better than other names I've tried. I keep ordering more. Comfortable, kind of addictive, and honestly practical for someone who needs real support.
Nice shoes, pricey try-on
I opened the box on a rainy afternoon, two pairs of shoes ready for trial — pretty good timing, I guess. One pair fit like they'd been broken in already, comfy and solid. The other looked identical online but just didn't match my vibe, so I decided to send it back. Delivery showed up on time and the staff were actually helpful; they answered my emails and even accepted a late return once I proved the pair wasn't worn, which I appreciated. The downside was the return cost and that the refund wasn't full; I paid $64.99 for the shoes, shelled out $13.75 to return them (no prepaid label), and only got back $51.99. So it turned into an expensive try-on experience. If you're ordering multiple sizes, be ready for possible return fees — that caught me off guard.
Small win, messy refund
Overall I'm pretty happy with the shoes, they fit my daily walks and the commute well, so I kept them. But the refund situation left a sour taste. I asked for an exchange because one shoe had two tiny factory blemishes on the sole. They called it "damaged" and offered a partial refund. I was told I'd get back the full amount if I closed the dispute. I closed it. Then they refunded less than promised and I still effectively paid shipping. Yeah, annoying. Still, the shoes themselves are comfy and I wear them a lot. Customer support needs to be clearer. Not perfect, but usable.
Saved prom, honestly
this actually worked out way better than I thought. I was skeptical — my kid wears a size 14 and normally lives in Vans, so formal shoes felt like a unicorn hunt. I first spotted them on Instagram (one of those targeted ads, weirdly useful) and tipped a mom friend about it. They had a huge selection, weirdly, and the pair we picked fit right away. Customer service answered my email in a few hours (big relief) and shipping wasn’t slow. My daughter put them on and immediately started posing — yep, felt like a queen in her dress. Happy with the whole thing, honestly.
Mixed feelings after first order
I ordered two pairs a few weeks ago and they arrived faster than I expected, which was a nice surprise. Opened the box, tried them on the same evening — one pair fit well and felt comfortable right away, the other was off. That’s when the hassle started. Returns are email-only and it’s been a slow back-and-forth for almost a week; I’ve only managed to get one pair approved so far. No phone support, no quick answers, and it just drags out. Delivery itself was solid and I’m glad one pair worked out, but the customer service for returns needs real improvement. I’ll be cautious ordering again.
Cautiously Satisfied
email back-and-forth for days, no phone, vague replies. After almost a week I finally got the return for the smaller pair processed, the second one is still in limbo. So yeah, annoyed by the process, pleased with the product that worked. Would buy again? Maybe, but only if I’m prepared to be patient.
Boxed surprise, but not the good kind
the cut clearly isn’t meant for wider feet and quality control seems off. I’ve bought sandals from smaller brands that fit wider feet better, so I had higher hopes here. Overall I’m skeptical but a little relieved the refund was quick. If they sort out width options and check the stock before sending, I’d give them another shot.
Finally they fit
the width actually fit, my foot didn't hang over the side, and there were no scratches. I wore them around the house that afternoon and then for a short walk the next day — still comfortable, though the straps were a touch stiff at first. Delivery was reasonable and the price felt fair for what I got. The service turnaround is what made me satisfied more than anything; quiet relief, really. I'd buy again, but I'll double-check everything on arrival.
My super cute shoes
Oh my goodness, I just got these awesome shoes and they are so stylish and cool. I seriously feel like a fashion icon when I wear them! Plus, they're actually really comfy so I can have them on all day without my feet killing me. The quality is top-notch, but I should probably make sure not to overwear them so they last longer. Customer service was alright, but it could've been better. But all in all, I’m totally in love with my new shoes!
Purple platform pumps
Customer service really knows what they're doing and they do it well! So, I ordered this super stylish pair of purple platform pumps not too long ago, but oops, I accidentally picked out the wrong size. Thankfully, the customer service team caught the mistake right away and got in touch with me to double-check the correct size before sending them out. It's rare to find that kind of attention to detail and proactive communication nowadays. I'm really grateful for all the effort they're putting in to make sure I get the right size. I'm super excited for my size 12 purple pumps to get here!
Assistance with updating email
I had a problem with my email when I was trying to place my order, but the folks at this place were super helpful and attentive. I didn't get any confirmation emails, so I wasn't sure if my order had gone through. When I contacted them, they found and fixed my email right away so I could keep track of my order. They responded to my email really quickly, even though I sent it late at night - I was really impressed. I just wanted to say a big thank you to the whole team for all their help and support. I really appreciate it!
Reliable and Trustworthy Customer Service
I had a problem with my order delivery, but the customer service team fixed it quickly and gave me a refund with no issues. I was really impressed by how efficient and professional they were. I'll definitely be coming back to shop again because of their trustworthy and reliable service.
Recent order experience
I just had an order mix-up, but the customer service team fixed it super fast. They were really professional and efficient. The shoes I got were top-notch quality, and I'm happy with how everything turned out. It's great that they paid close attention to fixing my mistake.
high heels in two sizes
There were so many high heels available on the website in every size, it was awesome. I rushed to order two pairs, but then I figured out I picked the wrong size. I contacted customer service right away to see if I could fix it before they shipped. They got back to me right quick the next day and said they could change the size no problem. Can't wait to get my high heels in the right size!
About Only Maker
Shoe lovers connect more to their collections rather than the rational beings that shop for shoes because of the necessity. In the eye of a shoe lover, all shows cannot be purchased, until they meet their qualifications. Then, what are the demand properties? There are many building principles; the notable ones are "style, design, and functions." Only Maker is a company that offers services in the distribution of shoe products. Do you think you can meet all your loved preferences in their collections? Kindly read on to ascertain that.
About Only Maker
Only Maker started in 2013 and created a designers group that has significant experience and love fashion as everyone that shops from them. With their "initial heart," they believe that they can make a difference in the "exceptional quality," "inspired fashion," and "considerable rate." The company shows that they are not perfect, but they would do their best to pursue perfection—the company focus on women's pursuit of Sexy Look and requirements for Comfort.
Products and services of Only Maker
The company shows that each shoe is carefully hand-crafted to bring you comfort and style, claiming that each item goes through strict sampling before being manufactured. Some of the notable products are "boots, sandals, pump, mid heels, among others."
Compliments, complaints, and tips Only Maker
Doyou own any of the company's collections? If yes, please tell us more about their services. Do you think Only Maker products are reliable? Can you repurchase from them? Please, share your experience and drop your feedback here.
Details
Contact Information
Categories Only Maker
Page Statistics
Last update: June 2026
Advertising notice: Some links are affiliate links. For purchases made through them, we may receive a commission – at no additional cost to you.
Review with most votes
High-quality shoes in larger s
I've been a loyal customer for years now, and I gotta say, the products they offer are top-notch. It's been such a relief to find shoes and boots in bigger sizes that ... Read onBy: Dimitri